Day Porter vs Night Crew ROI
Presence is a product — and it has a monthly price.
Compare the monthly labor cost of staffing day porters against a night cleaning crew. Enter your hourly wages, shift lengths, and payroll burden to see which deployment costs less or whether daytime visibility justifies the premium.
Instruction
- Enter the day porter wage per hour, hours per day, and number of porters on shift.
- Set the night crew wage per hour and hours per day, plus any night shift differential.
- Read the monthly cost for each model and the delta showing which option costs less.
Worked example
One day porter at $19/hr × 8 hrs/day vs night crew at $17.71/hr × 6 hrs, both with 22% burden over 22 working days.
Day porter ~$4,080/mo vs night crew ~$2,780/mo — about a $1,300 monthly premium for daytime presence (break-even near 5.5 day-porter hours).
Questions operators ask
- What is included in payroll burden percentage?
- Payroll burden covers employer-paid taxes, workers' compensation insurance, health benefits, paid time off, and other costs beyond base wages. For cleaning operations it typically runs 18-28% of gross wages depending on your state and benefit package. Enter your actual loaded labor rate to get an accurate comparison.
- When does a day porter cost less than night crew?
- Day porters cost less when their shorter shifts or lower hourly rate offset the night crew's longer coverage window. More often the day porter costs more but delivers real-time response to spills, restocking during business hours, and visible customer service that a night crew cannot provide. The delta tells you what that daytime presence costs.
- Should I add a night shift differential for the night crew wage?
- If your market or contract requires premium pay for overnight hours, enter that percentage in the night shift differential field. Common differentials run 5-15% above the day rate. If your night crew wage already includes the premium, leave the differential at zero to avoid double-counting.
